|
Post by aircarb on Nov 26, 2005 13:56:55 GMT -5
Is there anywhere local where I can get gas for my 1911?
|
|
|
Post by Guinness on Nov 26, 2005 14:44:25 GMT -5
Get one of these and you can use cheap propane- www.airsoft-innovations.com/Or you can buy PC Duster air and either alter the red filler straw to work on filling your magazine, or somewhere there is an adapter, I think maybe they sell an adapter kit with the butane refill kits- but PC duster air is like $5-10 bucks at Office Depot or Wal-Mart. You will also want to make sure you have a can of silicone spray (or siricone splay as it may be labled) to lube the rings and mag internals as the PC duster air does have that in the mixture. -G
|
|
|
Post by AADan on Nov 26, 2005 16:46:29 GMT -5
I use and recommend the propane adapter.
|
|
|
Post by Ajax on Nov 26, 2005 19:02:52 GMT -5
LOL is this for a WA 1911? I hope not.
Pc duster = too weak Propane = too strong.
Use hfc134a, the stuff it says to use in the instructions
If it's a kjw 1911, go ahead use whatever you want.
-Ajax
|
|
Russian
Corporal
Magician
Posts: 923
|
Post by Russian on Nov 26, 2005 19:51:04 GMT -5
I believe the question was where localy can he purchase it, not where otr what in general.
|
|
|
Post by mikkel on Nov 26, 2005 19:52:03 GMT -5
They (AI) also got an flow restrictor for WA guns, that allows you to use propane without damaging the gun.
|
|
|
Post by Capt. Zak on Nov 26, 2005 19:53:18 GMT -5
134A gas can be purchased at any auto parts store. You'll need to make a "Gordak 134A Adaptor" but it beats buying the 134A from Hong Kong.
|
|
Russian
Corporal
Magician
Posts: 923
|
Post by Russian on Nov 26, 2005 20:26:01 GMT -5
Hmm...can Gordak post pictures of the aforementioned adaptor?
|
|
|
Post by Guinness on Nov 26, 2005 21:10:28 GMT -5
Yikes you guys- HFC134a is PC Duster air- www.airsoftretreat.com/gbb_guide.aspThe young lad asked where to buy it "locally" so I pointed out the options the allow him an almost limitless supply of 'local air'- PC Duster or Propane- Obviously the Propane solution would require the installation of the airsoft innovations flow restrictor, which even if you watch the video on the site, is perhaps a bit more advanced that some of us want to tackle. Get a can of butane re-fill and there are adaptors in there to port the PC Duster air into your gun and voila! HFC134a in your tank! No more dependance on off-shore oil! ...er uh wait I mean off-shore air!! -G
|
|
|
Post by CPL. Mills 2nd Rangers on Nov 26, 2005 23:42:38 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Nov 26, 2005 23:55:16 GMT -5
"HFC134a is PC Duster air" LOL "kwc berreta has good durability" LOL
Believe what you want, but I woudl recommend you concider the following.
just look at the date on that article, Back almost in the dark ages of western hemisphere airsoft.
I dare you to take HFC 134a and use it to clean dust out of your computer DARE You. I used an m93r on 134 next to a guy using duster on the SAME gun, his slide could not lock back, while mine functioned perfecty. The 134a may have been same psi, but the rate of expansion made the difference.
Let me explain, its possible that some brands of compressed air computer cleaning bottles are a similar psi, but the expansion values would have to be different, otherwise people would dammage their computers from literally spraying ice on the circut board.
Propane just plain destroys guns, and its unsafe.
-Gordak
|
|
|
Post by Guinness on Nov 27, 2005 2:29:30 GMT -5
Gordak my good friend- Although I would never presume to argue with you, I would ask you this question- have you ever taken a can of PC duster air and either turned it upside down or even merely cocked it to the right slightly? The result is what you are referring to- The liquid propellant emerges. Regardless of the age of the referenced article, there are many "published" reports about these gases (published meaning on airsoft forums such as Arnies, etc.) that indicate hfc123a = duster air or by it's nerdy name, Tetrafluoroethane. Now they could certainly all be wrong, part of some world-wide consortium of evil-doers out to market their gases to the masses of airsoft users that don't want to pay $13 plus shipping dollars and wait 2 weeks for a 800ml can that has siricone splay in the mix. I know from experience that I have purchased green gas (HFC22/RF22) in the familiar camo-pattern cans in bulk from overseas and every one of the bottles I received had the rotten-eggs propane odor in them- that was my first clue that something was amiss- now did I do the dumbass test and try to light it like propane? negative. Do I believe that the articles and tests of these gases are correct? why not? Have the Japanese tapped some mysterious 'Airsoft only' reservoir of gas in their search for Godzirra and Mothra? doubtful- HFC-134a-Look at bottom of page under 'Material Safety Data Sheets' RF-22/HFC-22(R-22 Chlorodifluoromethane) -Basically the same refrigerant used in vehicles, non-flammable Propane(Propane C3H8) Flammable (Duh, it's propane!) but shares many properties with RF-22 refrigerant. www.airsoft-innovations.com/index.php?page=lab&id=greengas(Lab analysis of green gas/propane by C. Chong) So am I saying that you should use propane? not at all- what I am saying is that if you buy "Green Gas" from overseas you may already be using propane. The term Green in Green Gas really just means environmentally safe, or no ozone depletion. Many Japanese mfg's strictly advise against using so-called 'Green Gas' at all- Because of the higher pressure and potential risk to the plastic slides and internals (...or could it be the FIRE DANGER?? What did they know and when did they know it?? lol ) However, with the installation of metal slides and stronger internal components, most Japanese GBB's become 'safe' for the higher pressure gases. And in point of fact, often if you do 'upgrade' your gun, you need to use the green stuff to take advantage of the upgrades. Some Japanese mfg. already allow for green gas, Marushin's M1 Carbine for instance. So I agree with you Gordak, propane is bad- however the reality is that some of us have probably been using it for a while now- and it is cheaper and readily available, and I look at it this way- Potentially dangerous? yes- but it's use in an airsoft weapon has got to be safer than the 'intended use' of screwing the familiar green Coleman bottle into a BBQ grill, turning the valve and then shoving a match up under the grill because the electric ignitor has long-since quit working Let me see a show of hands on how many times we have all done that?? Your one example of a Kameraden using PC duster air aside, I am saying that we should be using PC duster air- Unless you can show me the difference between HFC-134a and.......HFC-134a ;D Perhaps he had 'other issues' than the air? -G
|
|
Russian
Corporal
Magician
Posts: 923
|
Post by Russian on Nov 27, 2005 2:48:51 GMT -5
Have the Japanese tapped some mysterious 'Airsoft only' reservoir of gas in their search for Godzirra and Mothra? doubtful-
Tee hee....had me in stiches for sometime with this one.
|
|
|
Post by AADan on Nov 27, 2005 4:35:34 GMT -5
Yep I converted over to propane when I did the same experiment I saw on AI's website and filled a syringe with Green Gas then lit it as I expelled the gas. IT's flammable propane is flammable so I use propane as my cheaper source of possible explosive death now. I don't use green gas guns very much anymore though. I have a couple but mostly I use AEG's and now I will have a classic running on HPA.
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Nov 27, 2005 19:20:50 GMT -5
Ok, so if duster is hfc134a, but is it held to the same purity standards as the AC Freon we put in our cars?
How much is duster? in winter, 12oz of 134a is $2.79 If the price is the same, I figure ill stick with 134a because i love my guns and dont feel like risking them to dammage.
ok, perhaps some greengas is propane, but is it the type you want to buy? I put fires out with moscart grenades, according to otheres it should have caused a massive explosion. So clearly SOME Greengas, is NOT propane.... Why is that the case? probably because some companies bend the law. Anything that is flamible, should by law, be labbled so. Im not saying your wrong, I just know what the gun is made for, and prefer to stick with it.
The reason I really like 134a, is becasue with my addapter, I can actually keep track of how much gas i put in the magazine, Very important if your going to trust your magazine in the battlefield.
-Sam
|
|
|
Post by Guinness on Nov 27, 2005 20:59:46 GMT -5
I hear ya Gordak, and I agree- really I do!
I just have the metal slides installed on many of my guns, my SCW WA 1911 for instance and she needs the green power.
-G
|
|
|
Post by mikkel on Nov 28, 2005 11:38:54 GMT -5
Green gas IS propane, the lab tests have proven this. End of story
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Nov 28, 2005 12:28:21 GMT -5
Guinness, you obviously know alot more than me about this so I belive and respect what you say.
Mikkel Lab tests say SOME green gas is propane
Guinness (again), I have a metal slide on my SCW ver 1 and hfc134 works fine with it., I dont know who made the slide though. -Gordak
|
|
|
Post by AADan on Nov 28, 2005 13:28:13 GMT -5
Appreciate that... I took a risk, a very small risk. If I had taken a can and lit it on fire you might be right. However that is not what I did. A small amount of Green Gas in a small hypo. (Diabetic syringe) was not enough to worry about. Lets not throw insults around. The'll kick me off this board before you know it and I like it here. Propane being safe: Of course there is a new PB gun made by Tippmann that runs off propane so I am not sure it is very unsafe to use. Add to that the safety record so far of Green Gas not exploding in guns. Although I did once see pictures of one that exploded in the back of a car on a hot day.
|
|
|
Post by mikkel on Nov 28, 2005 15:25:56 GMT -5
AADan> Yes, those pictures were quite nasty. Someone could have been killed by the shrapnel, it went right through the roof of the car!
Gordak> Yes, those tested was green gas. All green gas has to my knowledge, just about the same preassure. I would be very surprised if one airsoft company have been using some completely different gas. Did you blow out the fire quickly, or let the gas flow slowly? The fast release of the gas could instantly remove all the air around, and strangle the fire instantly.
|
|
|
Post by Guinness on Nov 28, 2005 15:58:00 GMT -5
Gordak, 1st,...you'd better cut it out- there is no way that I know more about anything than you- as I said in my first post here, you guys are GODS! I just have the power of GOOGLE! at my fingertips....and I read a lot of the forums in search of Airsoft news goodies for my addiction...er uh hobby Hey...Doh! maybe this is an excellent addition to the FAQ page- I mean here we have been discussing it and posting links to the info and whatnot and here comes Mikkel saying "Green gas IS propane, the lab tests have proven this. End of story"So the FAQ would be a great place to post some myth-busting info for beginners and 'veterans' alike, in perhaps a 'scholarly' but not too wordy presentation so that WW2AA could also become a resource across the net for Airsoft info! Clearly there are still alot of misconceptions and misunderstandings out there that could use some clearing up. Mikkel my friend, as Gordak and myself have said, some 'Green Gas' is propane, but certainly not all- It's kind of like saying "All Danish girls are blond and blue-eyed" See? that's certainly not true is it?..........I mean is it??? Cuz if it is, I need names man, NAMES! As well Gordak made a good point earlier- there are actually LAWS and stuff about the safe handling and transport of flammable gas, which apparently these bottlers and I would dare say some resellers are in 'cahoots' on, because obviously they are breaking them. For instance, I have a 1000ml can of "ET-1000" Green Gas in the familiar camo bottle that I bought in bulk on eBay, and it says on the side under contents: CHz FCF3 CH3 Well first off there is no such gas as that, but I did find a link to a Russian Airsoft forum that cleared the mystery up a bit- Russkie site that has good info....if you can decypher itNow, if you read Russian and, well, don't we all You will see that this 'mystery' gas (the can of ET-1000) is actually described as "Top Gas" or RF-22. Which in some circles, and this is where this whole thing starts to get fuzzy, is not in fact [glow=green,2,300]'Green Gas'[/glow] But,...well 'top gas' which isn't green gas and isn't red gas but I guess something in-between. But I'm here to tell ya, this bottle and the 7 others that came with it are...... propane- plain and simple. And yes, the inner-idiot in me won yesterday and I did in fact do the 'dumbass test' and syphon some of the remaining gas out of the bottle and yes Virginia, she's-a-flambe! And aadan, I wasn't referring to you specifically when I said 'dumba**', it's just kind of a silly thing to do don't you think? "Hey...let's see if it'll BURN!!" but as you see, I called myself a dumbass when I did it According to this Russian site and other reports I have read recently, 'Green Gas' was originally meant to describe HFC-134a- the gas that most Japanese mfg's rate their guns as using- However somewhere along the way, I guess in translating from Japanese to English and maybe even Russian, who knows, the whole 'color' thing got jacked up. So where does that leave us? For Japanese guns that have not been upgraded to metal components or internals, or that you want to make sure stay in 'factory specs' use HFC-134a- Sources of HFC-134a: -KWC 'Power Bombe' 134a -'Forane 134a Green' -Now this one is interesting, see, they even call it 'green' -PC Duster Air -With adapter from butane refiller to fill magazines. -Basically anything that says "134a" in the title or list of contents. I believe the 'Green Gas' 100ml cans listed on the Evike site are also HFC-134a even though the item description says HFC22: Evike Airsoft Gas pageConfused? Take a look at the 4th item from the bottom on that page- "RED GAS HIGH PRESSURE GREEN GAS" ....uh WTF? Red gas high pressure green gas?? My brain hurts. Here is what I believe[/i] is going on- I think the 'color standard' is all knackered up and means nothing anymore. I think there are actually three separate 'levels' of gases out there with four distinct 'varieties' of chemicals- Green Gas[/i] Top Gas[/i] Red Gas[/i] HFC134a- The lowest or 'weakest' commonly* available propellant (refrigerant) for Airsoft weapons. Required or at minimum strongly suggested by most Japanese manufacturers of GBB or gas-operated guns. Was originally called "Green Gas" and is still refrerred to as that by some Airsoft gas bottlers. RF-22/HFC22- Next in 'power' magnitude to HFC-134a or 'green gas'. Was originally called "Top Gas" and is still referred to as top gas by some bottlers. There seems to be a mix-up between some resellers listing their 'Top Gas' as 'Green Gas' and there also seems to be a few that list HFC-134a incorrectly as "HFC22" But who can really blame them? I mean have you ever read one of these bottles? "PUT THE TOY GUN CANISTER OUTSIDE OF THE DOOR QUICKLY WHEN IT UNDER FAST LE AKAGE OF THE CLOSE SPACE" uhhh yeah ok . I'm not making that up either nor the space between "LE" and "AKAGE" haha! Propane- Pretty much a toss up here- dependant on the bottlers understanding of hazardous materials laws, you may see some bottles called 'green gas' that they meant to be 'top gas' slip through filled with propane. I say that because some of the properties of Propane are similar to RF22/HFC22- it's pressure, etc., are similar so I believe this comes from the crowd that wants to rename top gas as green gas but fill the bottles with the cheaper propane. HFC-404a- "Red Gas" This is actually a 'blend' of 'Green' and 'Top' gases to make a 'slightly' more powerful mixture of gas. Certainly more expensive than the others and if the Japanese makers advise the use of HFC-134a, and some people are using 'Top Gas' and Propane in them and trashing the guns, what do you think this stuff will do?. Definately for upgraded guns and probably not worth the extra expense (my opinion) The moral of the story? If you want to be on the safe side, spend the extra money and get cans that specifically say "134a" on them- The ones I listed above all do- KWC, Forane- We now know that PC Duster air is HFC134a, if you want to save some $ then use that. As for propane, it's you or your guns funeral....kidding, I'm kidding! yeah it is cheaper than rolling the dice and buying what someone tells ya is green gas but should be top gas- I would say this- When it absolutely, positively, has to explode chunks of your $200+ dollar gun across the room and possibly ignite in your hands[/i] use propane (again, a joke) Use caution...and eye protection always......and a hazmat suit may be good to have handy..ok I'll stop ;D I really think the whole propane thing came from bottlers wanting to make even more profit by filling with cheap propane over expensive refrigerant- so take that into consideration when thinking about stocking up on green Colemans bottles- would you really be doing this if some overseas greedy bottler wasn't originally trying to maximize his coin and illegally ship a hazardous gas to those silly Americans and Euros? "Watch- these capitalist dogs will buy anything! I won't even hide the smell and they will end up buying more!! muhahahaha!" Kind of backfired on him though because our silly asses now actually believe that we are getting the last laugh!.......BOOM! they are still laughing * commonly Note- Gordak I think I have a possible solution to the "My friend used duster air in his gun and it wouldn't even operate the slide" conundrum- There is actually yet another not-so-commonly used gas (anymore), CFC12/R12 remember that stuff? you know, the reason-why-the-planet-is-going-to-burn-and-we-are-all-gonna-die gas??? Well turns out it was used in duster cans for a while and is under a bit lower pressure than even HFC123a. Yikes! I win!! longest post evah!!! -G
|
|
|
Post by AADan on Nov 28, 2005 16:05:29 GMT -5
well as long as your calling yourself a dumbass aswell I guess it's all good ;D Seriously though I felt it was a manageable risk and I don't trust the net so I had to find out myself. I would add that jsut because not all green gas/top gas what have you is propane. Your not likely to know which is and which isn't atleast with propane I know what I have for sure. If something changes and I blow off a limb while firing my gas gun I will be sure to type..one handed maybe but I will type a message of warning to you guys ;D
|
|
|
Post by CPL. Mills 2nd Rangers on Nov 28, 2005 22:35:18 GMT -5
Yea I seem to remember right before I got into airsoft, some guys I worked with, that were big into airosft, around 1999-2001 They had GBB guns, and when I questioned about airsoft he told me to use Green gas, SO I started to do my own research, and at that time, green gas was hcf134a gas. Then in late 2002 early 2003 the local army navy store got cheap airsoft guns in, with that cammo Green gas, and it seems to me, that ever since I ran into that stuff, online stores,(redwolf) stopped referring to 134a as green gas but 134a, then they still have Red Gas, HFC22 and they have green gas that they say is HFC22 as well. redwolfairsoft.com/redwolf/airsoft/Category?menu1=8&menu2=104#8706So yea, I think that when airsoft gained more popularity here, they hole color system fell apart.
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Nov 29, 2005 13:09:29 GMT -5
I have a bottle of "black gas"... the can has a snow flake on it, Im going to try it out this winter when its around 10 degrees outside! -Gordak
|
|
|
Post by staaf on Dec 12, 2005 16:29:45 GMT -5
I noticed the faulty review on the frontpage where it states that HFC 134a is 100% environmentally friendly, actualy its far from it so i recomend using Propane or something similar.
HFC 134a got a ODP of 1700points if i remember correct. The old R12 had a ODP of 8700points and propane got a ODP of 0.0. ODP= Ozone Damage Potential.
I for one take the risk of damaging my guns (never hapend so far after 6-7years) than spilling tha other crap into the air.
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Dec 12, 2005 17:29:40 GMT -5
"HFC-134a has zero ozone depletion potential (ODP) and is not targeted for phase out by the Montreal Protocol, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency or the Kyoto Protocol."
From the McQuay web site, Number one refrigeration company in the world.
Check the psi of propane, before you use it, thats all Im saying. -Gordak
|
|
|
Post by aircarb on Dec 12, 2005 21:03:49 GMT -5
What does everyone use in his or her 1911?
|
|
|
Post by staaf on Dec 13, 2005 0:27:13 GMT -5
dang, i am sorry i got the thing wrong, it was the GWP not the ODP i was talking about there. Thanks for correcting me. GWP of 1300 is the correct number. No more typing late at night.
|
|
|
Post by Gordak on Dec 13, 2005 23:22:25 GMT -5
I use hfc 134a in my Wa 1911s, its what they are made for. Dont forget so oil the mags occasionally, (silicone oil) they can really dry up!
|
|
|
Post by fallout on Dec 15, 2005 13:47:51 GMT -5
R-134a (Tetrafluoroethane) or CF2CH3, is a commonly used automotive refrigerant. As it contains no chloroflourocarbons, it replaced R-12 (dichlorodifluoromethane) in automobile refrigeration systems because of R-12's serious ozone depletional properties during the early 1990s (Montreal Protocol). They share similar thermodynamic properties, but only similar, and hence utilize a slightly different Brayton cycle. R-134a is almost nontoxic, and as a result it is often used as a pressurizing agent for such things as medical inhalers. It DOES have significant global warming potential, however, and as concentrations of R-134a in the atmosphere have risen significantly in recent years, and there is talk of it being phased out for automobile A/C systems at some point in the future.
R-22 (difluoromonochloromethane), or CHCIF2, is a commonly used residential and industrial refrigerant. Chlorodifluoromethane was first used as an alternative to the ozone depleting CFC-11 and CFC-12, but was later decided to be not environmentally friendly enough, although its ozone depletion potential is 0.05, among the lowest for chlorine-containing haloalkanes. It will be phased out soon under the Montreal Protocol, to be replaced by more environmentally friendly refrigerants such as R-410A (an azeotropic mixture of difluoromethane and pentafluoroethane), R-134A (1-1-1-2 tetrafluroethane) and R-409C. In short, this gas will soon be illegal and unobtainable.
Propane, or CH3CH2CH3, you guys all know. From Wikipedia: "Another use of propane is the application as propellant for aerosol sprays, especially after the ban of CFCs. So called "green gas" used in many gas-powered BB or airsoft guns is merely propane as the propellant with 100% silicone oil added to lubricate gaskets."
I have personally been using Propane in ALL of my gas-powered airsoft guns for going on 2 years now, with zero problems.
|
|